Friday, November 20, 2026

THE DISAPPEARANCE OF THE ROSE by PATRIA RIVERA

EILEEN TABIOS Engages



The Disappearance of the Rose by Patria Rivera 

(University of the Philippines Press, 2026)


BOOK LINK


The title reminds me of a poem I wrote in immediate response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on Feb. 24, 2022, a monostich or one line poem entitled “Kharkiv”:

 

All roses became gray

 

But the sense of disappearance—rather, the plural of disappearances—was partly unexpected for me in Patria Rivera’s debut novel, The Disappearance of the Rose. 

 

The novel’s strength results from the discernibly deep research Rivera undertook for her novel; the research provided the context for the life of primary protagonist Celing in the Philippines during World War II. Details under Japanese occupation through which she and others became comfort women and slaves are particularly harrowing. I also was taken by how she included and applied the story of how Filipinos came to be named after provincial Spaniards (based on one of her footnotes, we apparently were both inspired by Penelope Flores’ wonderful article in Positively Filipino about how Filipinos were given Spanish surnames to make it easier for taxes to be applied by Spanish colonizers.)


But a more fully embodied and palpable personal story seems also to disappear under the weight of the powerful historical facts—the novel spans a time period of before the Philippine Revolution against Spain to the end of World War II. Unlike in many fiction stories where a writer’s research stays secondary (whether as context or side notes or atmosphere) to the fictional story that is unfolding, here the researched history is so compelling it becomes the key focus. This is not necessarily negative: when one realizes the significance of the history that was researched, perhaps the right aspect is privileged.  

 

Indeed, I hesitate to second-guess the author’s decisions because the material contains plenty of examples of fine (from a literary standpoint), resonant, and moving passages. The author can write and writes well. But for the "historical fiction" that is The Disappearance of the Rose, Rivera pushed down the scale to give more weight to history. As a result, as a reader I feel I learned more about history than invested emotionally in the book's characters. 


Rivera's approach influenced the writing style. For instance, at one point, Rivera writes

 

It was a beautiful place, but no one even bothered to look, nor had the strength to look up or down or from side to side, from one end to another because it was really a sad place

 

That passage, to me, can be a metaphor. Rather than stating that a place is beautiful, a writer can flesh out details of the place that leads to beauty’s conclusion even if the word “beautiful” is not cited. But at the same time, would that showing be a waste of time when, the point is that “it was really a sad place” (for reasons described elsewhere in the book to which historically minded readers should attend)? Ultimately, the novel tells of other characters like Celing caught in a toxic historical spiderweb. The history cited in the novel emphasizes that Celing is not just an individual but a representative of many other women who suffered like her. To differentiate Celing, therefore, and make her more compelling as the primary protagonist over others, more had to be fictionalized about her life to make the reader care about her, specifically. On the other hand, if the author wanted to focus more on history, the novel as written achieves its goal.

 

As such, I recommend Rivera’s novel as a means for contemporary readers to know more about a history that should be known and feel the weight of that history. But equally important, I hope to read more novels from Rivera in the future since the quality of her writing is worthy of interest. Here is an example which exemplifies her prowess at fiction, even literary fiction:


FIRST MEMORIES

 

Ceiling awoke to insistent rain pelting the rusty corrugated-iron roof, heard the rat-tat-tapping of lizards’ tongues on the windowsill. The windows were shadowy with a moonless night’s passion. She thought she knew who she was, but out here, in tis damp and narrow entresuelo—a walk-up rental locals called accesoria—with a rusty sink and kerosene stove, she feels the world is so large she is descending into an unstoppable fall.



*****


Eileen R. Tabios has released books of poetry, fiction, essays, art and experimental prose from publishers around the world. In 2027 she will release a combined novel & poetry collection, Collateral Damage Blues. Recent publications include the poetry collections Engkanto in the Diaspora and Because I Love You, I Become War; a children’s book Tata Efren’s Forever Laughter (with Jeannie Celestial & Mel Vera Cruz); the novels The Balikbayan Artist and DoveLion: A Fairy Tale for Our Times; an autobiography The Inventor; the short story collections The Erotic Space Around Art Objectsand Getting To One; and an art monograph Drawing Six Directions. More information at https://eileenrtabios.com

 


No comments:

Post a Comment